Rum • Sweet
Three Dots and a Dash

Chicago’s tiki haven, Three Dots and a Dash, gets its name from a classic Don The Beachcomber tiki cocktail—so naturally the fruit-forward libation makes an appearance on the menu, albeit in highly customized form. The bar’s take on the drink is made with both a funky rhum agricole (beverage director Julian Cox likes the Rhum J.M. 100-proof aged 1-year) as well as a gold Guyanese rum (El Dorado 5-year, preferably). The bar also updated the cocktail by eschewing typical mass market ingredients for house-made. “Instead of the curaçao typically found in this drink, we brighten it up with fresh squeezed orange juice,” Cox says. “We make our falernum with almond, clove, allspice and lime. It has a beautiful citrus note that nicely dries everything out.” While we recommend home bartenders keep the fresh orange juice, making your own falernum and allspice  might be a bridge too far. If you’re going store-bought, Cox recommends Velvet Falernum and St. Elizabeth for your allspice dram.

The Essentials

Orange Juice
The Details
Contributed by


1.5 oz Rhum
.5 oz rum
1 oz Orange Juice
1 oz fresh lime juice
.5 oz honey syrup
.25 oz allspice dram
4 dashes bitters
3 cherries


  • Mix all liquid ingredients in a cocktail shaker filled with ice cubes.
  • Shake for ten seconds and pour into a tiki mug. Top with crushed ice.
  • Garnish with three cherries skewered to a pineapple "dash,” three small pineapple leaves and a 6-inch straw.